Site Meter

He loves and she loves

Just Causes

Password required

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

« TIME magazine ends debate on the war in Afghanistan? | Main | Typical summerish »

July 31, 2010

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834518c7969e2013485e5b2b1970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Tea Party to Peggy Noonan: It's not rage but disgust!:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

“We do not need an elite to govern us. We can govern ourselves.” These words say it all. Our founders knew this and drew a constitution based on freedom from government control. A small government is necessary to make sure we practice freedom and to defend us from those who would rule us by force. Hence the Tea Party spirit.

Re: that "Starfish/Spider" book. Eric Raymond wrote one called "The Cathedral and the Bazaar." You can guess which metaphor is the equivalent of which between the two books. Raymond was talking more about software development, the opposite poles being Microsoft and Linux, but the concept is the same. Or as a friend of mine put it (in another context): They're the dinosaurs and we're the small furry mammals who steal and eat their eggs.

Bottom-up self-organization being more powerful and agile than top-down control is certainly not a new idea; Adam Smith wrote about it too. The flattening of heirarchy in corporations in the 80s and the dotcom boom in the 90s was based on it.

Peggy is lost ... The idea motivating the tea party is simple and ever new ... Liberty and self government ... It is Peggy and her kind that must step out of the middle ages or their favorite Victorian novel and live life now

Why is it necessary for the Tea Party to be driven by "new ideas" when those who call themselves "progressives" want to "progress" by recycling the failed ideas of 70 years ago?
That is, 70 if you want to take it back to FDR. Only half that if you go back to half-wit Dhimmi Carter.

Not about ideas? Geez these people are just friggin' lame. Self-government, liberty, and the ability to make something without the government's guidance are all things alien to the uber-elite intellectual crowd. They disregard what they fear and at the end of the day they fear us ignoring them. Vestigial Americans like Noonan are trying to maintain some semblance of relevance after they slobbered praise over Obama and now look like utter fools. They can trash the tea parties all they want but the record shows we were right all along , have better ideas, and they were wrong and push ideas that flat out don't work. The ruling class has always hated the real achievers. The same way that those that talk a good game hate those that can actually play it. Noonan is just pissed that we threw the REAL party and she didn't get an invite.

Excellent points. The Tea Party seeks a return to the ideals that brought us thus far;
The government has pursued a path to illegitimacy

http://teaparty-editor.blogspot.com/2010/07/path-to-illegitimacy.html

BlogDog, you can go even further. Progressivism goes back to Marx and still more: its expression goes back to the Middle Ages.

During the Middle Ages, we saw the collectivism, the Progressivism, of the right: monarchies + theocracies.

Liberty is a higher form of politics than Progressivism, which simply replaces one aristocracy for another.

New ideas? Like what, socialized medicine? Unionism? The left has NO ideas. Their economics has already sunk to the bottom of the ash heap of history; none of the crap they believe about economics has been taught in an economics department in fifty years.

The tea party is not about new ideas...it is about old ideas which are being ignored. It is about the Constitution and the proper scope of government. If they want a new idea, I would propose a new Constitutional amendment:

"Go re-read the Xth amendment...we meant it."

Not "change" ... "change" BACK to what didn't work in the past.

The Re-, er, Progressive movement is about ideas that sound good.

The Tea Party Movement is about ideas that actually work good.

That teeny, weenie, 3-letter word "New". What mischief has it not caused over the past century?

@iGout: Not half as much as the four-letter word "free".

As many have said, the Tea Party is a Restoration movement.

It is based around classical liberal ideas, so yeah I guess they're pretty old. But the Left's ideas spring from the mind of that spry young whippersnapper Karl Marx.

If we're going to compare the ages of our respective ideologies, it's not like the modern progressives are singing from this year's hymn book.

The comments to this entry are closed.

The Cold Turkey Cookbook

Kudos

Blog powered by Typepad